Apple tries to avoid ads that say Samsung’s not at fault
| ||
Korean major Samsung wins the latest round, but the UK verdict only
suggests that the intellectual property war may go down to the wire
| ||
Christopher Williams & Alice Philipson
| ||
Apple has launched a bid to overturn a high court
judgment that orders it to run embarrassing national newspaper adverts
admitting that Samsung did not unlawfully copy the design of the iPad.
In a hearing before a panel of three senior judges on Monday, Apple argued that, in finding Samsung had not infringed its design, the trial judge had placed too much emphasis on differences between the design of the back of Galaxy Tab range and the back of the iPad. Michael Silverleaf QC, representing Apple, said the differences highlighted in the ruling amounted only to “decoration” that should not carry significant weight in judging whether Samsung copied. Whereas the back of the iPad is almost featureless, Galaxy Tabs have a separate, different coloured section along one edge that contains the camera and flash. The trial judge found these “unusual details” would mean people would not confuse the designs and that Apple’s minimalist design was “cooler”. “I say he was wrong to take these aspects [of colour] into account at all,” said Mr Silverleaf on Monday. “This [the iPad] is a design about shape. You don’t make a non-infringing design by making the same shape and decorating it.” More weight should have been given to the similarities between the front of the iPad and the front of Galaxy Tabs, he argued. Both designs have a thick black border around their rectangular touch screens. “Too much weight was given to the features of the back and far too little weight to the features of the front,” said Mr Silverleaf. He argued that the trial judge’s ruling that the iPad and Galaxy Tabs belonged to a “family” of earlier devices that included the LG Flatron, a PC monitor with a similar flat screen with a black border, was incorrect. Only Samsung’s design shared enough features with the iPad to be considered part of the same “family”, Mr Silverleaf said. Giving less weight to similarities in their front appearance because older devices also looked similar was therefore wrong, he claimed. The British case is part of a complex global battle that pits Apple against Samsung in intellectual property courts in Europe, the US, South Korea and Australia. Apple believes its main rival “slavishly” ripped off designs and technologies from both the iPad and iPhone in its Android smartphones and tablets and scored the biggest victory so far with a £664m damages award in California. Finding in favour of Samsung in July, the British trial judge ordered Apple “to put advertisements in the relevant newspapers and to put a statement on their United Kingdom website”, admitting its Korean rival had not infringed the iPad design. Henry Carr QC, representing Samsung, on Monday accused Apple of wanting a monopoly over the basic features of a tablet computer. He insisted that the trial judge was right to find that Samsung had exercised its design freedom where it could – on the back of its Galaxy Tabs – and that contrary to Apple’s claims, he had considered each alleged infringing feature individually and as a whole. Mr Carr also accused Apple’s legal team of “exaggerating” images in its appeal submissions to make it appear that the iPad and Galaxy Tabs were closer in thickness, whereas the trial judge found Samsung’s designs “look very much thinner than the Apple design”. “That is important to the informed user,” the trial judge said. The panel of three appeal judges retired to consider their judgment. If Apple loses again, it could apply to the Supreme Court. A separate hearing will consider Samsung’s claim that the registered iPad design is invalid anyway. Daily Telegraph |
Tuesday, October 2, 2012
Korean major Samsung wins the latest round, but the UK verdict only suggests that the intellectual property war may go down to the wire
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts
-
Click here to see Original Photo Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj - Great Maratha King
-
Click here to see Original Photo Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj - Great Maratha King Shiwaji weapons
-
1 Land, Politics And Trade In South Asia: 2 Leadership In 21st Century: 3 Truth Is Multi Dimensional-CD Sri Sri Ravishankar Art 4 What ...
-
Click here for More articles Rashichakrakar Sharad Upadhye - Bhakti Sagar आखाडा का बखेडा? : शरद उपाध्ये - Rashichakra Sharad Upadhy...
-
Kokanatala Malvani Garana Garhana marathi garhane कोकणात देवाला गार्हाणं घालण्याची रीत अजूनही प्रचलीत आहे.चांगल्या प्रसंगी देवाची आठव...
-
आषाढी (देवशयनी) एकादशी इतिहास पूर्वी देव आणि दानव यांच्यात युद्ध पेटले. कुंभदैत्याचा पुत्र मृदुमान्य याने तप करून शंकराक...
-
स्त्रीला गरोदर कसे करावे ? पाहण्यासाठी येथे या मातृत्व प्रत्येक विवाहीत स्त्रीच्या आयुष्यात मातृत्व प्राप्त होणे ही अत्यंत आनंदाची तस...
-
Marathi Bold Actress Amruta Khanvilkar When Amruta Khanvilkar was the losing fina...
-
CLICK HERE TO VIEW THIS INFORMATION
-
सुरस कथा मार्केटिंगच्या Dhirubhai Ambani Marketing Story in Marathi कथा धिरुभाई अंबानी यांचे वडील गुजरातमधे ग्रामीण भागात प्राथमीक शीक...
Total Pageviews
Categories
- Mehandi Designs (1)
- rail chakra (18)
- rel chakra (17)
- relchakra (18)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(1722)
-
▼
October
(226)
- Industrial design competition
- titles in our stock
- Fancy Nameplates for house doors
- Industrialist Akanksha Rathi found dead
- Security guard at Mahim ATM attacked
- Tough times for commuters will continue. After the...
- Biker crashes into Uddhav’s wife’s car at Kalanaga...
- Firemen don’t need life insurance, compensation gi...
- MODI MOCKS PM, CALLS HIM MAUN MOHAN SINGH
- Largest publisher: Random House, Penguin merge
- The Secret Series Complete Collection - Pseudonymo...
- In search of the lost children Families of the ki...
- ‘Cancel Wadia hospital lease’
- Twenty women ran away from a government-run women ...
- 10,646 Indians jailed abroad and forgotten
- A SIGN OF CHANGE As Belapur gets set to celebrate ...
- AFFORDABLE LUXE LIVING Luxury affordable housing o...
- The realty sector urgently requires the government...
- Rudraksh helps in stabilising and anchoring the bi...
- DUBAI VISA IS NOW OFFERED FOR FREE
- Get home décor that dazzles
- Answers queries from readers on property matters a...
- Govt steps in to protect poor kids in schools
- Home guard hurt in the eye at Currey Road stn
- No new teaching college: State Govt will not affi...
- Couple smuggles watches, held Watches worth Rs1.8...
- baby boy stolen from Nowrosjee Wadia Maternity Hos...
- NGOs, med council laud court order on PCPNDT Act
- People are forwarding chain mails which claim that...
- Two days after Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray made ...
- Anticipating a rise in noise pollution during Diwa...
- City felicitates astronomy Olympiad winners Team ...
- Soundtrack to history: 1878 Edison audio unveiled
- Comedian Jaspal Bhatti killed in car accident
- Wrestling Between Two Cute Babies
- Springer Verlag titles
- Jejuri Mahakhanda Dasara - 42 kg sword lifted by t...
- Mehta publishing house contacts Marathi Book selle...
- New Editions
- Dropping of the words “Mao Zedong thought” from tw...
- Polls say combative Obama trumps subdued Romney in...
- King of Spain Juan Carlos I will be on a state vis...
- Bangla to Beed: Love’s labour lost 20-yr-old cros...
- LPG cap to up your hospital bills Higher costs of...
- Ex-chief secy, 25 state babus booked Initially es...
- Around the World in 80 Days is a popular movie tha...
- Roll up your sleeves for Sindoor Khela Bidding Go...
- HuJI threat: 14,500 cops fan out to likely terror ...
- A first in 40 years: Sena to tone down Dussehra rally
- HC lets the music play Refuses to cancel nod for ...
- received following titles in our stock
- New titles
- SEPT AND OCT NEW RELEASES FROM PENGUIN
- PENGUIN NEW RELEASE
- नजर दोष और उपाय
- Ex-chief information commissioner says wrongly mar...
- A CLOSE LOOK AT THE CHANGING TEACHING-LEARNING PRO...
- What does it take to reach out to a student — info...
- विलक्षण संग्राहक! नगरचे सुरेशराव जोशी SURESHRAO J...
- Ark Hotel Construction time lapse building 15 stor...
- विद्यार्थ्यांच्या ‘नजरबाणांपासून’ बचावासाठी शिक्षि...
- एका मिनिटात १०० अब्ज फोटो - Ramesh Raskar: Imaging...
- Beware of this killer pole Pole no. 12/2 on Harbo...
- Aug 11 riots mastermind arrested Cops claim the t...
- 36% children don’t get pocket money as their spend...
- titles in our stock
- Why saraswati is ignored Our obsession with worsh...
- A goddess among men Appreciates the charms of bei...
- Durga puja’s colonial roots The tradition of comm...
- A salt mine may seem like an unlikely tourist spot...
- Fiction’s got back it’s mojo
- In The Green Room, Wendell Rodricks is like a kind...
- Was Valmiki using Ram and Lakshman to clear Dandak...
- State commission reserves order in autistic child ...
- The rise of Vadra’s Nagar Mahesh Nagar held the p...
- At the Ramkrishna Math and Mission in Khar, seven ...
- Abducted kid rescued in 24 hrs
- WHY THE CHILD MAY RUN?
- For tiny tots, Navratri is all about little Golu d...
- Kunal Kapoor interview
- सिनेमॅटोग्राफर महेश लिमये - Mahesh Limaye Cinemato...
- Amitabh having back pain
- अर्धवट तोडलेला लंगर - Marathi Movie Langar Review
- Saif and Kareena kiss
- Review - "Student of the year" Hindi Movie
- १० ‘मस्ट’ आर्थिक गोष्टी - 10 must know Financial M...
- INORGANIC CHEMISTRY: A MODERN TREATISE D. Banerje...
- Attack police, lose passport
- MCOCA for 68 chain-snatchers, jeweller in Thane
- Do looks mean you would also have a good nature?
- Times Utsav. The event promises to be a haven for ...
- Is Aadhar not a valid ID proof?
- 31 Author: Upendra Namburi - Book Review
- Author Manreet Sodhi Someshwar talks to After Hrs ...
- Bickram Ghosh sets new percussion record
- penguin October new release
- Panel moots law to protect privacy ‘Unclear regul...
- CM’s right on 50-year vision
- Meditate for better agri yield! Yogic agriculture...
- Loser not weeper, helpline comes in handy
-
▼
October
(226)
No comments:
Post a Comment